Easter Baking Ideas for a Hoppy Holiday

In America, Easter afternoons are spent hunting around the yard for sweet surprises left by Peter Cottontail.

Elsewhere, like Bermuda, Northwestern Europe, and France, the holiday is celebrated by flying a kite, lighting a bonfire, and making an omelet respectively. 

But one thing many cultures have in common when it comes to Easter is celebrating with a sweet treat, whether it’s candy, chocolate, or cake.

So don’t stress about what to bring to Easter lunch or dinner—we’ve got you covered.

What Are Some Popular Easter Desserts?

Depending on who you ask, different people may have different opinions on what a classic Easter dessert is.

One person might say cake, another might say cookies.

That said, there are some desserts that generally tend to show up on Easter tables across the board:

• Carrot cake or cupcakes
• Sugar cookies
• Lemon cake or pie
• Chocolate-covered marshmallows
• Bread pudding
• Fruit cobbler
• Banana pudding 
• Strawberry shortcake

So what should you bring to your Easter gathering or bake at home to celebrate?

The good news is, there’s no right or wrong answer.

Let’s look at some options, from traditional treats to non-traditional ones.

Traditional Easter Baking Ideas We Love

The nice thing about showing up to Easter dinner with a more traditional recipe is that it’s sure to be a hit.

Here are some of our favorites:

Lemon Meringue Pie

This pie is a classic for a reason. Its bright color and tangy taste are perfect for springtime holidays like Easter. Plus, it pairs well with marshmallowy whipped cream!

Italian Easter Cookies

These cookies are similar to sugar cookies in that they have a buttery, melt-in-your-mouth texture that’ll have you going back for more. Plus, the colorful sprinkles suit the season.

Charoset Truffles

Passover is a meaningful Hebrew holiday that takes place around the same time as Easter. Charoset truffles are a bite-sized take on a Passover dinner tradition and a great way to celebrate the holiday.

Non-Traditional Easter Baking Ideas for Those Who Want to Mix It Up

Of course, you don’t have to stick to the same old song and dance when it comes to Easter desserts. Here are some of our favorite non-traditional Easter treats.

Persian Love Cake

Love is always in season, and this cake is perfect for spring celebrations with its fragrant floral flavors and vanilla base.

Churros Baking Kit

You could make bunny-shaped cookies or chocolate-covered marshmallow eggs—or you could make churros. These sweet treats are always a good choice, no matter the occasion. 

Honey Walnut Cake with Fig Frosting 

Another option with floral influence, this cake features notes of orange blossom accented by rich honey and vanilla and a touch of lemon zest.

Need an Easter Basket Gift Idea?

Our baking kit subscription makes a great gift for those who love cooking things up in the kitchen or want to get into baking. Each month, subscribers choose from our rotating menu of globally inspired recipes. Then, we deliver the goods: pre-measured, shelf-stable ingredients and easy-to-follow instructions.